Contents
Introduction
Homelessness and Violence
Tribal-Based Advocacy Services & MMIWP
Community-Based Advocacy Services
Child Advocacy Center
Forensic Exams
Domestic Violence Protection Orders
Sexual Assault Protection Orders
Law Enforcement Calls for Service: Sexual Assault
Law Enforcement Calls for Service: Domestic Violence
Domestic Violence Perpetrator Opportunity for Treatment Services
Lethality Assessment Program
Domestic Violence High Risk Team
Intimate Partner Violence Fatalities
Introduction
Sexual and domestic violence are common in Whatcom County and around the world. Using different ways to look at these problems can help us better understand them. This can then improve how we prevent and respond to violence. In 2024 The Bellingham-Whatcom County Commission on Sexual and Domestic Violence spent time assessing these problems using a public health lens. Public health, as defined by Whatcom County Health & Community Services, means:
Promoting health through policy and systems improvement;
Preventing disease and injury;
Providing accurate and reliable health communication, information and data;
Preparing for and respond to emergencies; and
Preserving a healthy environment where everyone can thrive.
This data report captures some of the incidents of violence in our community, and also some of the responses. There are different ways to measure the frequency and impact of domestic violence and sexual assault. We can look at police reports, but we know that most incidents go unreported. We also know that many survivors experience a pattern of power and control that occurs 24/7. That cannot be captured in a police report. We can look at the number of people served by organizations like DVSAS, LVOC, Tl’ils Ta’á’altha, and Brigid Collins. But we also know that not everyone has access to or seeks out these supports. This report provides data from different sources to help us piece together a picture of sexual and domestic violence in Whatcom County.
Homelessness & Violence
Violence and homelessness are linked. The threat of homelessness traps survivors in abusive relationships. Escaping domestic violence may lead to homelessness. People experiencing homelessness are targeted for sexual and domestic violence.
The data below show a connection between violence and homelessness in our community. Nationally we see this connection, too. At some point in their life, 5.5% of all women in the United States need housing services after experiencing intimate partner violence. Other data "indicate that women experience disproportionally high levels of [sexual violence] before, during, and after episodes of homelessness. Homeless women have often experienced victimization by multiple perpetrators, beginning in childhood and extending into adulthood." A survey of advocates in 29 states found that almost 60% had worked with at least one survivor who had been sexually assaulted by their landlord, property owner, or property manager.
What can we do to disrupt this relationship between violence and homelessness? We know that affordable housing is a protective factor against sexual and domestic violence. How can we provide that housing?
One way we can prevent homelessness is by preventing sexual and domestic violence. One way we can prevent violence is by ensuring that housing is available to all.
Sources: The National Intimate Partner and Sexual Violence Survey, Housing & Sexual Violence Research Brief
On average, more than 1 in 4 households on the Whatcom County Coordinated Entry Housing Pool (homeless households on the waitlist for housing) in 2023 were fleeing or attempting to flee domestic violence, dating violence, sexual assault, stalking, human trafficking, or other dangerous or life-threatening conditions that relate to violence against the household member(s). Source: Whatcom Homeless Service Center
Though the percentages have decreased, well over 1/3 of youth (ages 18-34) served by Northwest Youth Services Housing Programs had experienced domestic violence at some point in their lives, and close to 1/5 were fleeing domestic violence in 2023.
Rates of youth experiencing domestic violence were higher in Northwest Youth Services' Critical Transitions case management program. 65% had experienced domestic violence at some point in their lives and one of every four youth were fleeing domestic violence.
Critical Transitions is a case management program for youth that have left a system of care (like foster care, juvenile detention, incarceration, inpatient hospitalization for substance abuse disorder or inpatient hospitalization for mental health) within the last year.
What is the Commission doing to address homelessness and violence? What can I do?
Commission members and staff support aligned efforts throughout Whatcom County. This helps us address the needs of survivors along with other public health issues, including homelessness and access to housing. Our Toolkit to Respond to Sexual and Domestic Violence includes a section for housing providers. The 2017 Data Report features a spotlight on homelessness and housing instability.
Where can I learn more?
Healthy Whatcom data dashboard on Housing Affordability in Whatcom County
Most recent Whatcom County Point-in-Time Count Report
Tribal-Based Advocacy Services & MMIWP
Lummi Victims of Crime and Nooksack Tribe’s Tl’ils Ta’á’altha Victims of Crime provide culturally responsive services for survivors in our community, including tribal members and non-members.
Lummi Victims of Crime
Lummi Victims of Crime (LVOC) serves survivors 24 hours a day with crisis counseling and Ne-Alis Tokw (My Sister’s Place) Domestic Violence Shelter. LVOC also provides legal advocacy, therapy referrals, traditional healing, and emergency assistance.
Tl’ils Ta’á’altha means “To love and honor oneself.” This program of the Nooksack Indian Tribe started in 2020 and serves survivors 24 hours a day with crisis counseling, emergency housing and transportation, referrals and legal advocacy.
Nooksack Tribe's Tl’ils Ta’á’altha program served 40 survivors in 2023. This includes 1 survivor seeking support related to sexual assault and 39 seeking support for domestic violence. Source: Tl’ils Ta’á’altha
Missing & Murdered Indigenous Women & People (MMIWP)
The crisis of missing and murdered indigenous women and people impacts our community. An average of 4 Lummi Tribal Members are missing each year. Most of these cases involve young people who have run away. This might mean that they are fleeing violence. Youth who have runaway are often targeted for violence, including sexual violence, dating violence, and human trafficking. In the U.S. and Canada, over 40% of sex trafficking victims are Native Americans or First Nations, even though they make up only 2.9% and 5% of those populations, respectively.
In November 2024 the Commission on Sexual & Domestic Violence, in partnership with Community Consortium for Cultural Recognition, Domestic Violence & Sexual Assault Services, Lummi Victims of Crime, Mount Baker Foundation, PeaceHealth, PeaceHealth Tribal Alliance Group, Unity Care NW, and the Washington State Women’s Commission, hosted the Whatcom County Summit on Missing and Murdered Indigenous Women & People.
Community-Based Advocacy Services
The number of individual clients served has remained relatively steady for four years after a big drop in 2020.
While the total number of clients did not increase significantly, of the average number of contacts per client in 2023 exceeded pre-pandemic averages.
Medical advocacy increased dramatically from 2022 to 2023. Medical advocacy usually means an advocate responds to PeaceHealth St. Joseph Medical Center to support a survivor having a forensic medical exam. It can also include providing support for other medical appointments. Medical advocacy for sexual assault forensic exams stayed about the same. Medical advocacy for domestic violence forensic exams increased from only 7 in 2022 to 81 in 2023. This was due to a change in protocol at the hospital. In these domestic violence cases, the survivor has been strangled. Strangulation is extremely dangerous. Yet, it can also be difficult to identify evidence of strangulation at the scene. Forensic nurses have special training to identify evidence of strangulation, and provide essential treatment.
Most students who received services sought support for sexual assault. Students self-identified the reason for seeking support and were able to select more than one reason.
Fewer individual students accessed advocacy services in 2023 compared to 2022. This brought the number back to 2020 and 2021 levels (89 and 86 students, respectively). However, more students accessed support groups.
Based on the Survivor Advocacy Services satisfaction surveys over the past three academic years the top 5 reasons students accessed services were:
- Emotional support related to experience of violence and/or abuse. (82% of responses)
- Counseling support.
- Connect to resources on and off campus.
- Coping skills and self-care practices.
- Talk through the dynamics and effects of violence.
Students also accessed services for legal/reporting options, safety planning, academic advocacy, housing/financial/medical support. Source: WWU Survivor Advocacy Services
“I worked with the WWU survivor advocate to gain back some control over my academic career after an intense trauma. I found it most helpful when I was able to talk about my struggles, and I didn’t have to explain what solutions I needed. My advocate took that weight off my shoulders and gave me some solutions within Western's options... I don’t know what I would have done without a survivor advocate like her." - Student Survivor
Child Advocacy Center
Brigid Collins’ Children’s Advocacy Center (CAC) is a specialized facility designed to support and protect children who have been victims of abuse or neglect. The center offers a coordinated approach to handling cases of child abuse by bringing together various professionals—such as law enforcement, child protective services, medical personnel, and mental health professionals—in one location.
In 2023, Brigid Collins Family Support Services’ Whatcom County Children's Advocacy Center conducted 142 forensic interviews an almost 40% increase from the previous year.
Nearly 3/4 of children interviewed were under 13.
Offenders knew the child they abused. Of the 142 children who were interviewed by Brigid Collins Child Advocacy Center, almost 60% were abused by a relative. Another 23% were abused by a parent's partner or another known adult.
87% of children interviewed had experienced sexual violence. Many had also experienced neglect, physical abuse, and/or witnessed domestic violence.
Across the country, experiencing sexual assault as a child is very common. 1 in 2 female survivors and more than 2 in 5 male survivors first experienced unwanted sexual contact before age 18. Almost half of female rape victims were under 18 when they were first raped. About 57% of male victims experienced rape before age 18. Sexual coercion before adulthood is also common. 39% of female victims and 30% of male victims first experienced sexual coercion before 18. Source: The National Intimate Partner and Sexual Violence Survey
Forensic Exams
PeaceHealth has offered forensic care services since the mid-2010s. Before then, some emergency department nurses were trained forensic nurses, but they were not always available. At first, the specialized training was available to experienced emergency room nurses. This subspecialty of nursing requires extensive didactic training followed by multiple observed cases by a seasoned forensic nurse. Forensic nurses care for patients who have experienced sexual assault, domestic violence with strangulation, pediatric sexual assault, and pediatric child abuse. The training is extensive. The number of qualified forensic nurses nationally is about 1% of all registered nurses. In 2023 PeaceHealth St. Joseph Medical Center established its own forensic department. St. Joe's is working to staff the department 24/7 with qualified, forensically trained nurses from all areas of nursing.
A forensic exam can address many of the immediate harmful impacts of rape. Forensic nurses provide treatment for infections and injuries and offer emergency contraception. They also connect the survivor with a trained advocate from DVSAS or LVOC. This advocate can help the survivor create a safety plan and can provide ongoing support.
Survivors of rape experience immediate harmful impacts:
The number of forenensic exams conducted at St. Joe's have increased beyond pre-pandemic levels.
More than 1/4 Of the 170 forensic exams at St. Joe's were for children under the age of 13. These include 37 child sexual abuse cases and 13 cases of other abuse and/or neglect. The remaining 71% of cases were for adults and adolescents.
Forensic nurses spent 720 hours conducting forensic exams at PeaceHealth St. Joseph Medical Center in 2023. Source: PeaceHealth St. Joseph Medical Center
In 2023, exams took, on average, 4.25 hours to complete. This is less than the 4.5 hours on average in 2022. Source: PeaceHealth St. Joseph Medical Center
Survivors who sought exams at St. Joseph Medical Center had experienced the incidents throughout the region: Whatcom, Skagit, Snohomish, Island, San Juan, and King Counties. Source: PeaceHealth St. Joseph Medical Center
Domestic Violence Protection Orders
Nationally, over 12% of women needed legal services due to intimate partner violence in their lifetime. The estimated number of women victims who needed legal services is more than 15 million. This is different from needing help from law enforcement. Source: The National Intimate Partner and Sexual Violence Survey
What is a Domestic Violence Protection Order (DVPO)?
Someone who has experienced domestic violence from an intimate partner or a family or household member can request a DVPO. An intimate partner can be a spouse, boyfriend/girlfriend, or romantic partner. Domestic violence may include controlling behavior, sometimes called coercive control. It can also include physical violence or threats of physical violence. Someone may also apply on behalf of a family or household member who is a minor or vulnerable adult. A judge or commissioner can grant or deny this order. If it is granted, it protects against domestic violence or threat of violence. It can make it illegal for the other person to contact or come near the victim. According to Washington State Courts, someone who has been sexually assaulted, harassed, or stalked by a partner or a family or household member should, but is not required to, seek a DVPO, instead of another type of protection order. Source: Washington State Courts
Whatcom County Superior Court Domestic Violence Protection Order petitions rose sharply in 2023. There were 275 petitions compared to only 122 the previous year. 83% were granted temporary orders. About half (49%) were granted final orders. These final orders usually last for one year and a petitioner may file a motion to renew the order. Superior Court has jurisdiction over Domestic Violence Protection Order cases when the petitioner and respondent are currently married, currently living together, or have a child in common.
Whatcom County District Court receives fewer Domestic Violence Protection Order petitions than Superior Court. District Court has jurisdiction over these cases when parties are an intimate partner or family member, but who are NOT married, do NOT live together, and do NOT have a child in common. About 25-50% were granted temporary orders in the past 5 years. In 2023 over 1/3 were granted final orders. These final orders usually last for one year and a petitioner may file a motion to renew the order.
DVSAS saw a corresponding increase in survivors seeking legal advocacy. This includes assistance with domestic violence and sexual assault protection orders, with an increase of over 61% in legal advocacy contacts from 2022 to 2023.
Why have petitions increased?
We don’t know for sure why petitions have increased and it is likely due to a number of factors. Some possibilities include increased ease of access and increased awareness of the process. Protection Orders can now be filed in person, by email, or by mail.
Nooksack Tribal Court received 4 Domestic Violence Protection Order petitions in 2023. One was granted a final order. This is down from 7 petitions filed in 2022.
Justice for Families Project
The Commission on Sexual & Domestic Violence is working with DVSAS, LAW Advocates, and Superior and District Courts, to improve civil court processes for survivors. This includes domestic violence protection orders, sexual assault protection orders, parenting plans, and divorce. We want to improve these processes so they are accessible, easy to navigate, trauma-informed, and procedurally just for survivors of domestic violence, sexual assault, and stalking. This Justice for Families project will have a special focus on language access for survivors for whom written and spoken English is not their first language.
Sexual Assault Protection Orders
What is a Sexual Assault Protection Order (SAPO)?
Someone who has experienced nonconsensual sexual conduct, even if it only occurred once. A single incident of nonconsensual sexual conduct is enough for a petition for a SAPO. A judge or commissioner can grant or deny this order. If it is granted, it can make it illegal for the other person to contact or come near the victim. Source: Washington State Courts
Compared to Domestic Violence Protection Orders Whatcom County District and Superior Courts receive very few Sexual Assault Protection Order (SAPO) Petitions.
District Court has received 11 or fewer SAPO petitions for the last four years. 14-45% were granted temporary orders. Fewer than half were granted final orders. Like domestic violence protection orders, some petitions are denied a temporary order but granted a permanent order.
Superior Court receives fewer SAPO Petitions, with 3 or fewer petitions filed in each of the last 4 years. Instead, petitioners may be seeking domestic violence protection orders, as sexual violence can fall under the requirements for a DVPO depending on the petitioner's relationship to the respondent. One SAPO was granted a final order in each year 2019-2022, and in 2023 three petitioners were granted a final order.
Violations of Protection Orders and criminal No Contact Orders are common. In 2023, Whatcom County reported 371 violations of these orders, meaning that the accused, offender, or respondent contacted the victim or violated other terms of the order. Source: Washington Association of Sheriffs and Police Chiefs (WASPC) Crime in Washington Annual Reports
Justice for Families Project
The Commission on Sexual & Domestic Violence is working with DVSAS, LAW Advocates, and Superior and District Courts, to improve civil court processes for survivors. This includes domestic violence protection orders, sexual assault protection orders, parenting plans, and divorce. We want to improve these processes so they are accessible, easy to navigate, trauma-informed, and procedurally just for survivors of domestic violence, sexual assault, and stalking. This Justice for Families project will have a special focus on language access for survivors for whom written and spoken English is not their first language.
Law Enforcement Calls for Service: Sexual Assault
Most sexual assault is not reported to law enforcement. The U.S. Department of Justice estimates that in 2023 only 46% of rapes/sexual assaults were reported to police. This is a big increase from the previous year when only 21% were reported. Though we do not have statistics specifically about our own community, we can estimate that acts of sexual violence are actually much higher than what is reported in Whatcom County each year.
Reports of sexual violence in Whatcom County have continued to decrease. However, because most sexual assaults are not reported, there is no reason to believe that rates of sexual violence have decreased.
Whatcom’s largest law enforcement agencies receive fewer reports of sexual violence than they did in 2017.
Reports to Whatcom's 2nd and 3rd largest cities fluctuate. With fewer than 20 reports per year, it's difficult to identify trends.
These four small departments have received 6 or fewer reports each year since 2017.
Where are the 2023 numbers? These data (excluding BPD’s sex crime investigation data below) come from the Washington Association of Sheriffs and Police Chiefs (WASPC) Crime in Washington Annual Reports. Each year there are updates to the previous year’s data. From 2017 to 2023, the change in the official number of reported sexual assault offenses for a specific year ranged from an increase of 4 to 21 reports across Whatcom law enforcement agencies, with an average increase of 12.6 reports for a specific year. Including 2023 numbers might misrepresent the trend. The updated numbers will be included in next year’s Data Report.
In 2018 Bellingham Police Department began tracking some reports as sex crime investigations. These are not included in the WASPC Annual Crime in Washington Reports. In 2023, BPD also conducted 491 follow-up sex crime reports, up from 370 follow-ups in 2022. Source: Bellingham Police Department
Law Enforcement Calls for Service: Domestic Violence
Like sexual violence, domestic violence reports to law enforcement only represent a portion of what is happening in our community. The U.S. Department of Justice Bureau of Justice Statistics defines domestic violence as violent victimizations that were committed by current or former intimate partners or family members. Even those are underreported, with only 48% reported to police in 2023. This does not include other forms of domestic violence that do not meet that definition of violent victimization, including some coercion and threats, intimidation, emotional abuse, isolation, minimizing, denying and blaming, using children, using privilege and financial abuse. See the Power and Control Wheel for more information about tactics of abuse. 1 in 6 women and 1 in 18 men in the U.S. needed help from law enforcement at some point in their life as a result of contact sexual violence, physical violence, or stalking by an intimate partner. We also know that not everyone who needs that help is able to access it. Sources: The National Intimate Partner and Sexual Violence Survey and US Department of Justice
In 2023, Bellingham Police responded to nearly half (47%) of all domestic violence calls for service, a higher proportion than its share of Whatcom County's population that year (41%).
This chart includes all domestic violence calls for service: calls where officers made an arrest, and calls where officers determined that there was not enough evidence that a crime had occurred and did not make an arrest. Even in those calls where no arrest was made, an abusive person could have still caused harm to a survivor because the tactics used to establish power and control are harmful, even when they are not illegal.
Domestic violence calls where an arrest is NOT made have consistently made up more than half of all DV calls for service throughout Whatcom County. This is one way to look at the prevalance of domestic violence, because it shows incidents that have escalated to the point that someone (survivor, offender, neighbor, family member, etc.) has called for help, even if what happened doesn't meet the legal definition of domestic violence.
Nearly 9 of every 100 domestic violence offenses in 2023 were aggravated assaults. The Washington Association of Sheriffs and Police Chiefs defines aggravated assault as "An unlawful attack by one person upon another wherein the offender uses a weapon or displays it in a threatening manner, or the victim suffers obvious severe or aggravated bodily injury involving apparent broken bones, loss of teeth, possible internal injury, severe laceration, or loss of consciousness." These are serious assaults that could have caused the death of the victim. Firearms are the most frequent kind of weapon involved statewide, but "personal weapons" (hands, fists, feet, etc.) fall closely behind. Throughout Washington, 16.8% of aggravated assault victims were in an intimate relationship with the offender.
Domestic Violence Perpetrator Opportunity for Treatment Services (DVPOTS)
Lack of providers and cost are two barriers to accessing court-mandated perpetrator treatment. Since 2021 Whatcom County District Court has had a program to pay for treatment for those unable to pay. Domestic Violence Perpetrator Opportunity for Treatment Services (DVPOTS) funds domestic violence perpetrator assessments and treatment for qualifying defendants.
About 33 defendants have engaged with DVPOTS each year over the past 3 years. These numbers include individuals who remained engaged from the previous year, or started in the current year.
Lethality Assessment Program
The Lethality Assessment Program (LAP) was developed by the Maryland Network Against Domestic Violence and is based on the research of Dr. Jacquelyn Campbell. Dr. Campbell’s work showed that women killed by their intimate partners had very seldom been engaged by advocates.
When a law enforcement officer responds to a domestic call, the LAP protocol directs them to:
- Conduct an 11-item lethality screen with the victim. The questions focus on the victim’s level of danger to be seriously injured or killed by their intimate partner.
- If the victim screens in at high risk of lethality, the officer makes immediate contact with the local domestic violence advocacy agency. In our community, this agency is DVSAS.
- The victim is then encouraged, but not required, to speak with the domestic violence advocate. The responding officer and the domestic violence advocate work as partners to provide the victim with safety planning and resource information.
Domestic Violence High Risk Team
The goal of the Whatcom County Domestic Violence High Risk Team (DVHRT) is to prevent domestic violence homicides. This multidisciplinary team identifies the most dangerous domestic violence offenders using research-based risk assessment tools and improves systemic responses for these offenders through coordinated communication.
45 cases were actively monitored by Whatcom's DVHRT in 2023 including the 6 cases accepted for monitoring that year. Source: Domestic Violence & Sexual Assault Services
Intimate Partner Violence Fatalities
There has been one intimate partner fatality in Whatcom County so far in 2024. There were none in 2023.
On June 6, 2024, retired WWU Dance Professor Nolan Dennett was murdered by his partner James Anthony Singleton.
We can prevent domestic violence fatalities.
How do systems support or limit survivors’ options? How can systems hold abusers accountable and support abusive people to be non-violent? Local and state fatality reviews provide recommendations to prevent DV homicides in our community and throughout Washington State.